My ‘desired fate/solution for half of the Jews living on earth today – those who live in Israel?’?*

My ‘desired fate/solution for half of the Jews living on earth today – those who live in Israel?’?*

Desired fate: I wish them peace, I wish them life, I wish them freedom from being oppressors, exilers, occupiers, besiegers & dispossessors of another people in their homeland.

Desired solution: a free, secular, democratic Palestine (Israeland), as I described it in lines I wrote about a year and a half ago & am now publishing here as a meme:


That’s my desired solution, still, but of course it depends on enough people wanting it, on both sides.
& if they don’t, well then, each individual “Israeli” Jew in Palestine will make their own decision: whether or not to continue living as a citizen of the colonialist Zionist State whose very existence depends on the continuing dispossession & oppression etc of the country’s native population; whether or not to continue living in false consciousness, bad faith, denial that there is an occupation, that there are Palestinians, that there is a Palestine that for non-Jewish Palestinians is not “Israel”…

I’m not religious, but I’m with the rabbi who said that when there is persecution we should be on the side of the persecuted, not on the side of the persecutors. Or, to bring that down to basics: if your privileged life depended on your having to abuse and oppress someone else every day, would you choose to continue with that, or give up your privileged position?

You may think that because I’m a Jew my solidarity should be with the state where ‘half of the Jews living on earth today’ live. Well, it isn’t, not as long as that state continues to be an oppressor. My solidarity is with the oppressed & their struggle. Palestine must be free. & when the Arab Palestinians are freed from the Zionist oppression, the Hebrew Palestinians too will be freed from having to be the agents of that Zionist oppression.

* I was asked this question in a comment to a comment I  made to another post: ‘The Zionist State that occupies Palestine is based not on dignity & compassion but on Israeli-Jewish (& still primarily Ashkenazi) supremacy & privilege. & it can have no “democratically elected leader” when around half of the population of the country does not have the right to vote.’




Umar al Ghubari: I’m an Incited Palestinian

ani palestini musat

[My translation. You can read the original Hebrew, published on Local Call, here.]

I’m an Incited Palestinian

Yes. Right. I’m an incited Palestinian. Every day they incite me. My most prominent and significant inciters are the leaders, the commentators and most of the journalists of the State of Israel, and ordinary Israelis too. Social networks and the masses of Israeli talkbackers are a volcano of incitement. It’s clear to me that they want to incite against Palestinians, but their words come back like a boomerang and incite the Palestinians too.

A newscast on one of the Israeli television channels is a proven recipe for angering and inciting Palestinian viewers. Analyses and predictions by Zionist commentators are aggression and provocation to Palestinians. The despicable verbiage of people who call themselves “experts on Arab matters” is laden with slander and manipulations that arouse disgust towards Arabs, and when Arabs hear them they mainly feel dread and explode in anger.

Yes, it’s they who incite me and make me fume. Every time an Israeli leader relates to Arabs, to Palestinians, or to any other formulation he draws from these words, he expresses with alarming naturalness the hostile, racist, patronizing, threatening and humiliating attitude towards them. There is no doubt that the present Prime Minister is a star in this context, but he hasn’t invented a thing. He may have improved the method and embellished the formulations, but he has no exclusivity over racism. We relate to his words and his actions in these days only because he is the apex of the pyramid of the regime, not because he is exceptional or much more extreme than the Israeli prime ministers who preceded him.

This attitude towards the Arabs in general and the Palestinians in particular is deeply rooted in Zionist thought. Although it is expressed in different ways, in diverse formulations and in various doses, at its base this is a consistent line that stems from a racist world view, whose seeds were planted with the crystallization of the idea of establishing a Jewish state in Palestine. In his book The Jewish State (1896), Herzl wrote: “We should there [in Palestine] form a portion of a rampart of Europe against Asia, an outpost of civilization as opposed to barbarism.” Which Israeli leader has not believed, expressed himself, or thought in a similar way?

The majority of Palestinians understand Hebrew. They sit watching the television screens in one of their ghettoes, in Galilee, in Wadi ’Ara, in the center of the country and in the Negev, they hear the threats and absorb the humiliations poured into their faces from the Israeli TV channels. They’re incited even more by the claim about the only democracy in the Middle East that they are benefiting from. This maddens them. Frustrated, they look out the window to seek and to feel the democracy that isn’t there.

The Prime Minister attacks us, preaches to us and wants to educate us, and each of these teaching sessions is one more dose of incitement, not only against the Palestinians, but also of the Palestinians. Each address of this kind sounds like a call for an uprising. This kind of approach necessarily increases the impulse of rebelliousness. What incites us is everything that Zionism has created around us. Those who incite me are not the Arab leaders, not from the Palestinian Authority, not from the Islamic movement, and not from Balad. For incitement, they’re unnecessary. Who needs them when there’s the State of Israel, its leaders, its branches, its deeds, and a large number of its Jews?

Those who incite me are those who forced a Greek airline to remove two Palestinian Arabs from a plane, those who shout at a wounded Palestinian boy “Die, you son of a whore”, those who sing out “Death to the Arabs” in front of the public and the cameras, those who have destroyed the village of Al-Arakib more than 90 times; the fact that people are living in the houses of Palestinian refugees in Ein Hod, in Talbiyeh, and in Beer Sheva; those whose herds of cattle piss on the graves of Palestinians in Yalu (Canada Park), in Simsim (Gvaot Bar) and in Kafr Sabt (Sdeh Ilan); those who have built hundreds of settlements for Jews and not one for Arabs; those who invest nine times more on a Jewish student than on an Arab student, those who are Judaizing the country, and those who are currently carrying out a revenge action in ‘Ar‘ara.

Oh, at any given moment we’re encompassed by countless things and people that incite us, and there’s no way of evading them.

And despite all this we restrain ourselves.


Say Thanks

In exchange for this restraint, the Israelis should invent a weekly custom of thanksgiving. From the Prime Minister to the ordinary citizen, through the ministers, the members of parliament, the policemen, the judges, the educators, the merchants and all the other Jews living in this country. Let them start their week, every week, every Sunday morning, preferably at the same time, with a prayer like this one:

“At the beginning of this week, before we start working, we want to once again express our thanks and appreciation to the sons and daughters of the Palestinian people, to those whom we conquered in 1948, we expelled most of them and prevented their return, we destroyed their towns and their villages with their schools, their prayer-houses and their cemeteries, we dispossessed them of their lands on which we built hundreds of Jewish settlements, and to this day we’re continuing to oppress them – and to those whom we conquered in 1967, we expelled some of them, we stifled their towns and their villages, we dispossessed them of their lands, we took control of their treasures, we built new settlements among them despite their opposition, and to this day we’re continuing to oppress them and persecute them, to limit their movements, to enclose them and to deny them their freedom. To all of you, male and female, in town and in village – in what remains, in the ghettoes and the refugee camps, we want to thank you for the fact that this week too you have continued to restrain yourselves and have not risen up and revolted against the Jewish dictatorship in your country, the land of your birth. Thank you very much.”


[Umar al Ghubari is a group counselor, a political educator, and is documenting and photographing the Palestinian Nakba]